Mystic Pizza II was created as a smart answer to overwhelming demand after the 1988 film made the original location a global attraction. In 1991, the family expanded to North Stonington to serve guests who wanted the experience without the long waits.
Keep the Mystic Pizza legacy authentic and welcoming—family-led, consistent, and built around the recipes people come back for (especially the signature sauce and cheese blend).
Our classic, small or large. Also sold by the slice.
Chicken, eggplant or veal, baked with marinara, Parmesan and mozzarella, with pasta and garlic bread.
Served with marinara sauce for dipping.
Family meals made simple—pizza night classics and comfort favorites for everyone.
Guests often describe Mystic Pizza II as friendly, relaxed and easy for families and big groups.
Built to serve the same family recipes with less hassle—order ahead and enjoy the classics without the wait.