Menu

Our Menu

Appetizers

Boneless Buffalo Tenders

Tossed in our own hot sauce and served with blue cheese and celery.

11.75

Mystic Nachos Grande

Corn tortillas layered with “carne con queso” (meat & cheeses) garnished with black olives, tomatoes & jalapenos, served with salsa & sour cream.

14.50

Chicken Wings

Served with hot sauce, blue cheese and celery on the side or "Buffalo Style"

13

Chicken Tenders

Lightly battered chicken breast strips served with marinara sauce.

11.50

Homemade Onion Rings

Lightly battered, thinly sliced, and crispy fried.

9

Mozzarella Sticks

Lightly breaded fried mozzarella served with marinara sauce.

10.75

Fried Calamari

Lightly breaded native calamari served with hot pepper rings & marinara sauce.

13.50

Combo Platter

Combination of wings, tenders & mozzarella sticksserved with French fries & dipping sauce.

15.00

Garlic Bread

Hearth baked bread served with garlic seasoned butter oil.

6.75

Four Cheese Garlic Bread

Hearth baked bread seasoned with olive butter oil, baked with fresh garlic, mozzarella, provolone, cheddar & parmesan cheese served with marinara sauce.

9.25

French Fries

Golden fried premium Idaho potatoes served mountain high.

7.25

Chips & Salsa

Warm tortillas served with salsa & cheddar cheese sauce.

9.25

Sweet Potato Fries

Coasrse cut Idaho sweet jumbo potato fries .

8.00

Soups & Deli Sandwiches

Clam Chowder

World Renouned Chowder

Cup 6.00 / Bowl 7.00

Soup of The Day

Made Fresh Daily

Cup 6.00 / Bowl 7.00

Deli Sandwiches

Turkey, Ham, Tuna, Roast Beef,BLT, Mystic Reuben Served with Lettuce, Tomato & French Fries.
(Substitute Salad for Fries – $1.50)
Choice of: White, Wheat, Rye Bread, Kaiser Roll or a Wrap

11.25

Texas Chili

Add cheese & onions: 1.50

Cup 6.00 / Bowl 7.00

Join the Club

Turkey, Ham, Roast Beef, Tuna,or Cheeseburger Club Sandwich Served with Lettuce, Tomato & Bacon.
Served with french fries or pasta salad on your choice of white, whole wheat or rye bread.

14.75

Soup & Deli Sandwich

11.75

Soup & Salad

Choice of cup of soup & dinner salad. Make it a bowl: add 2.00

11.50

Slice & Salad

“Slice of Heaven” with fresh garden greens. Only cheese & pepperoni available.

11.50

Salads

Greek Salad

Feta cheese, grapeleaves, peperoncini.

13.50

Chicken Caesars Salad

Crispy romaine lettuce, parmesan cheese, tossed with Caesars dressing and topprd with marinated grilled chicken & croutons.

14.00

Garden Salad

Romaine lettuce, Kalamata olives, red onions, bell peppers and cherry tomatoes.

10.50

Antipasto Salad

Pepperoni, salami, ham, provolone cheese

13.75

Julienne Salad

Ham, Roast Beef, turkey, provolone cheese

13.75

Tuna Salad

White tuna, shredded cheddar & mozzarella & pickels

13.50

California Chicken Salad

Grilled chicken bacon, American cheese

15.50

Mystic Love Salad

Tricolo pasta, grilled chicken, gorgonzola, bacon bits

15.00

Buffalo Chicken Salad

Tender chicken strips, hot sauce, bleu cheese

14.50

Greek Chicken Salad

Tender char-broiled chicken, feta cheese, pepperoni, stuffed grape leaves & grilled pita bread.

15.50

Tuscan Salad

Garden greens, walnuts, pecans, cranberries, apples, gorgonzola cheese, balsamic dressing.

15.50

Mediterranean Salad

Gyro, feta cheese, kalamata olives, pepperoncini peppers, artichokes, stuffed grape leaves, yogurt cucumber garlic dressing, DELICIOUS!! served with warm pita bread.

15.50

Burger With The Works Salad

Angus beef patty, grilled mushrooms, bacon topped with gorgonzola & American cheese, served with out Love dressing.

15.50

Grilled Chicken Salad

Marinated char-broiled chicken breast.

14.00

Pizza

choose our traditional pan or our new thin crust pizza

Small: 10" – 8 slices

Large: 14" – 8 slices

 

Plain

One Item

Any Two Items

Any Three Items

Any Four Items

Small

10.00

11.00

12.00

13.00

14.00

Large

16.75

18.15

19.55

20.95

22.35

Toppings

Pepperoni

Chicken

Broccoli

Tomato

Bacon

Meatball

Pepperoncini

Olives

Anchovy

Pineapple

Mozzarella

Pastrami

Mushroom

Onion

Sausage

Ham

Eggplant

Green Pepper

Salami

Feta

Fresh Mozzarella

Fresh Basil

Fresh Garlic

Chooped Clams

Jalapeños

Spinach

Artichoke

Gorgonzola

Roasted Green

Peppers

Roasted Red

Specialty Pizzas

House Special 15.55 / 23.85

Pepperoni, Meatball, Sausage, Green Peppers, Onions, Mushrooms

Vegetarian Delight 15.05 / 23.35

Green Peppers, Onions, Mushrooms, Tomatoes, Broccoli

Grecian Delight 14.60 / 22.85

Pepperoncinis, Feta, Tomatoes, Black Olives, Garlic & Oregano

Margherita (thin crust only) / 19.50

Plum Tomato, Fresh Basil, Garlic, Fresh Mozzarella

Hawaiian 12.50 / 19.55

Ham & Pineapple

Barbecue Chicken 12.00 / 19.05

Chicken, Barbecue Sauce

Moussaka 13.00 / 20.45

Eggplant, Meatball, Extra Sauce

Seafood Delight 16.05 / 25.60

Shrimp, Clams, Scallops, Garlic & Oregano

Mediterranean Delight 14.85 / 22.55

Artichoke Hearts, Roasted Red Peppers, Spinach, Tomatoes, Garlic

Meatza 15.55 / 23.85

Sausage, Meatball, Pepperoni, Salami & Bacon

Chicken Gorgonzola 13.50 / 20.95

Chicken, Gorgonzola, Artichoke Hearts

Texas Chicken 14.25 / 22.10

Chicken, Red Onion, Bacon, BBQ Sauce

Buffalo Chicken 13.00 / 20.00

Buffalo Chicken with Blue Cheese dressing on the Side

White Pizzas

John Gotti’s Clam Casino / 22.95

Chopped clams,bacon, garlic, extra virgin olive oil, fresh mozzarella and parmesan, fresh basil

Marco’s Chicken Florentine / 21.50

Baby spinach, chicken, feta, fresh mozzarella, parmesan

Quatro Formaggio / 21.00

Ricotta, feta, parmesan, fresh mozzarella, extra virgin olive oil

Julia’s Special / 22.95

Fresh eggplant, baby spinach, roasted red peppers, feta, parmesan, fresh mozzarella, ricotta, extra virgin olive oil

Chicken Broccoli / 22.35

Chicken, broccoli florets, fresh garlic, ricotta, parmesan, fresh mozzarella

Taco Mexicana / 22.95

Seasoned ground beef, jalapeño, red onion, sharp cheddar cheese, sour cream, diced tomatoes, lettuce

Party Sheet Pizza

Cheese

1 Item

Any 2 Items

Any 3 Items

Any 4 Items

Grinders

Selected quality meats, cheeses & vegetables served on your choice of crispy or soft Italian bread, hot or cold, small or large. We use 100% pure olive oil. Cabbage may be substituted for lettuce.

Meatball Grinder

Handmade meatballs, basil marinara, provolone cheese on fresh baked grinder rolls.

Small 9.30 / Large 10.30

Steak n Cheese

Shaved sirloin steak smothered with provolone cheese.

Small 10.80 / Large 11.80

Chicken Parm Grinder

Tender white meat, basil marinara, provolone cheese

Small 9.80 / Large 10.80

Meatless

Small 8.75 / Large 9.45

Salami

Small 9.00 / Large 10.00

Ham

Small 9.30 / Large 10.30

Tuna

Small 9.30 / Large 10.30

Bacon

Small 9.30 / Large 10.30

Genoa Salami

Small 9.30 / Large 10.30

Turkey

Small 9.80 / Large 10.80

Roast Beef

Small 9.80 / Large 10.80

Italian Combo

Small 9.80 / Large 10.80

Chicken

Small 9.80 / Large 10.80

Pepperoni

Small 9.80 / Large 10.80

Pastrami

Small 9.80 / Large 10.80

Cheeseburger

Small 10.30 / Large 11.30

Fish

Small 10.30 / Large 11.30

Sausage Parmesan

Small 9.30 / Large 10.30

Eggplant Parmesan

Small 9.30 / Large 10.30

Calzones

The Cheeser

Made with our own "Secret Recipe" sauce, mozzarella & ricotta cheese.

11.50

Mystic Calzone

Pepperoni, sausage, mushrooms, onions, tomatoes, mozzarella & ricotta.

14.75

Chicken Athena

Chicken, spinach, feta, garlic, mozzarella & ricotta.

14.75

Veggie Calzone

Broccoli, green peppers, tomatoes, mushrooms, spinach, mozzarella & ricotta.

14.50

Burgers

8 oz burgers. Sandwiches below served with french fries & cole slaw. Substitute sweet potato fries for $3.50.

Hamburger

With lettuce & tomato.

12.75

Cheeseburger

8 oz burger with lettuce & tomato and american cheese.

13.00

Burger with the Works

With lettuce, tomato, onion, mushrooms, melted cheese, & bacon.

15.00

Pizza Burger

With "Mystic Sauce" & mozzarella cheese

14.00

Gyro Platter

Tender strips of gyro smothered in garlic yogurt cucumber sauce wrapped in a pita with lettuce, onions, & tomatoes.

14.00

Chicken Souvlaki

Tender chicken breast smothered in garlic yogurt cucumber sauce wrapped in a pita with lettuce, onions, & tomatoes.

13.50

Fried Fish

Golden fried Cod fish topped with tartar sauce, lettuce, tomatoes.

13.50

Chicken

8 oz. skinless breast of chicken. Sandwiches below served on a Kaiser roll with french fries & cole slaw. Also available as a wrap. Substitute sweet potato fries for $2.50.

Grilled Chicken Sandwich

With lettuce, tomato, and mayonnaise.



13.00

California Chicken Sandwich

With lettuce, tomato, bacon, American cheese & lite ranch dressing.

14.00

Buffalo Chicken Sandwich

Served with hot sauce, lettuce & tomato.

13.50

Dinners

Add a dinner salad to any dinner: 5.50

Baked Lasagna

Layers of meat & cheese baked to perfection, served with garlic bread.

16.00

Eggplant Parmesan

Thin slices of breaded eggplant baked with marinara sauce & mozzarella cheese, served with pasta & garlic bread.

16.00

Chicken Parmesan

Chicken breast lightly breaded, smothered with marinara sauce & mozzarella cheese, Served with pasta & garlic bread.

17.00

Spaghetti with Meatballs

Italian style meatball made with ground veal, parmesan, served with marina & garlic bread.

14.00

Seafood

Seafood entrees served with french fries, cole slaw, our famous tartar sauce & garnished with lemon wedges. Cooked with Canola oil (no trans fats)

Fish & Chips

Lightly breaded atlantic cod
Available original batter.

16.50

Fried Bay Scallops

Fresh off the docks from Stonington, CT.

21.50

Fried Calamari

Atlantic calamari from our native waters.

18.50

Side Orders

Cole Slaw

4.50

Pasta ( Spaghetti or Shells)

8.00

Vegetable of the Day

8.00

Mac and Cheese

8.00

Dinner Salad

7.50

Beverages

2 Liter Drinks

Coke and Diet Coke

4.00

1 Liter Drinks

Coke, Diet Coke, Sprite and Ginger Ale

2.75

20oz Drinks

Coke, Coke Zero, Sprite, Ginger Ale, Fanta Orange, Apple Juice, and Dasani

2.75

Vitamin Water XXX

3.75

Beer List

Beer Menu

Wine List

Wine Menu

Martinis & Cocktails

Martini Menu

Desserts


Dessert Menu 1
Dessert Menu 2

  • Mystic Pizza 2
  • 211 Providence New London Tpke.
  • North Stonington, CT 06359
  • (860) 599-3111